Nameless Rumia's Wiki

I'm tired of the internet!

User Tools

Site Tools


lifespan_of_a_community

Lifespan of a Community

Lifespan of a Community (コミュニティの一生(いっしょう)) is a Japanese kopipe that had, presumably, originated on 2channel in 2006. It served as an explanation about how communities go through a rise and a fall, much like your three-act structure in narrative fiction.

Precursors

If you want to skip to the actual kopipe, click here.

On December 24, 2005, an anonymous 2channel user made a /gline/ thread titled “Guidelines for Starting a Thread [Spoiler]” which gave a detailed critique of how the board's threads routinely go through a cycle of peaking in popularity, devolving over time as people leave, then it pathetically ends with the holdouts clinging on.1) However, this version is considerably wordy and extremely specific to this board's situation.

1、スレッドが立つ。
2、技術のある人間がAAを提供して盛り上げる。
   感動を求めて人が集まってくる。
3、オリジナルAAを書ける人間が乗ってきてさらに盛り上げる。最盛期。
4、盛り上がりに乗じて何も書けない魯鈍と白痴が寄ってきてスポイルする。  ←いまここ
   彼らの無駄な愛着が逆効果を及ぼし、スレッドのレベルが著しく低下。
5、飽きて大勢が去っていき、行き場の無い魯鈍と白痴が残される。
   低レベルな自慢・偏見の陳列、煽りあい、無駄な罵倒、
   いわゆる「2ちゃんねる用語」を多用したお寒いレス等々が並ぶ。
6、煽りと罵倒しか出来ない魯鈍まで魯鈍同士の空疎な煽りあいに飽きて去る。
7、何も提供できない白痴が過去の栄光の日々を夢見て空ageを繰り返す。
   脳死状態
1. A thread is established.
2. Skilled people provide AA as a way to liven things up.
  People start to gather in search of inspiration.
3. People that are able to make original AA start piling on. The height of prosperity.
4. Taking advantage of the momentum, imbeciles and retards spoil the fun.  ← You are here
  Their pointless attachment has an adverse effect, and the thread quality significantly degrades.
5. Many people get bored and leave, leaving the imbeciles and morons with nowhere to go.
  It gets filled up with low-level displays of pride and prejudice, provocation, unnecessary insults,
  heavy use of so-called '2channel slang', and other terrible posts.
6. Even the imbeciles, who can only provoke and insult, get bored of these hollow exchanges and leave.
7. Retards who offer nothing constantly bump the thread and reminisce about the glory days.
  Brain death status.

Then on February 25, 2006, 2channel founder Hiroyuki Nishimura came up with a condensed, three-step outline in a /news/ thread to explain why their 'chatroom-type' (雑談系, zatsudan-kei) boards, which do not focus on a particular genre or topic, become rather homogenized or straight-forward and lose their perceived edge.2) In this version, Nishimura simply reduces the cycle to a binary.

初期:
面白い人が面白いことを書く
中期:
面白くない人が面白いものを見に来る
終末期:
面白くない人が面白くないものを書き始める
Early stage:
Interesting people write interesting things.
Middle stage:
Boring people come see interesting things.
Final stage:
Boring people start writing boring things.

Summary

At some point, an anonymous user came up with a broad outline, or flowchart, that can be broadly applied to most communities, but this version makes a better attempt at pinpointing the issue. It claims that ordinary people will settle in and become defensive about the space, pushing isolationist rhetoric or 'tourist' arguments, which end up turning interesting people away and, in turn, cause the community to stagnate.

【コミュニティの一生】

面白い人が面白いことをする
↓
面白いから凡人が集まってくる
↓
住み着いた凡人が居場所を守るために主張し始める
↓
面白い人が見切りをつけて居なくなる
↓
残った凡人が面白くないことをする
↓
面白くないので皆居なくなる
[Lifespan of a Community]

Interesting people do interesting things.
↓
Since it's interesting, ordinary people gather.
↓
Ordinary people begin to settle and assert that they must 'protect' where they belong.
↓
Interesting people give up and leave.
↓
The ordinary people remaining do boring things.
↓
Since it's boring, everyone leaves.

Notes

  • For some cases, the symptoms could easily be as simple as: an aggressive 'minimod' or 'backseat moderator', an attention seeker, a socially conscious snob, or the kind of person who ties everything to sociopolitical issues on either side of the aisle. However, take it with a grain of salt.
lifespan_of_a_community.txt · Last modified: by namelessrumia